For progressive reloaders with an automated bullet feed, the double-end wadcutter (DEWC) was designed, simply a cylinder beveled on each end. Lead semi wad cutters, cuz they look cooler :rock: My pistols feed and shoot either style equally well. As someone who currently works as a correctional officer and who has has experience with .38 special wadcutter rounds shot out of older model smith and wessons. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, which supports our community. Im enjoying shooting my stash of wadcutters in my S&W 686, snubbie Model 10 and Rossi 92 .357 carbine. For that matter so are wadcutters and semi-wadcutters. The Fora platform includes forum software by XenForo. I think the real reason the bullseye shooters liked the bullet is you could get less recoil( due to less weight) and still get flatter trajectories than the 230 for their 50 yard targets. Semi-Wadcutter Hollow-Point (SWHP) Semi-wadcutter hollow-point (SWHP) rounds are bare-lead bullets with a hollow point . I tested the Hornady 110 Critical Defense, and it does a very good job, for a JHP. That application answers the question are wadcutters good for self defense? The surprising answer to that question is yes. Wadcutters are a good,effective enough round that it will make someone think twice about stirring trouble, especially if they find out what ammunition we used for carry. Pasted as rich text. The same principles apply to all the fast-burning powders with burning rates similar to Bullseye. Even if it does not work out in pistols, I suspect that the Honey Badger load for a backup or snubbie may just be the perfect load of the future. Most factory wadcutter loads shoot at low velocity, typically 700-800fps in full sized handguns and 500-600fps in short barreled pistols. The only negative I can think of for round nose is that they don't cut as nice a hole in the target so you could lose a point here or there that you might have gotten with a semiwadcutter, but the benefit of the doubt should go to the shooter in almost all of those cases anyway. Mike (nMW), Thats an interesting observation on painting sights, Mike. shes just a girl. The protocol revolutionized the way that manufacturers designed and tested their ammunition, and gave the industry a common standard for the very first time. Absolutely not. May 27, 2005. dougk, Talking pistol cartridges only here; It is generally established that bullets with a meplat, or flat, on the nose will create a larger wound channel, create more tissue damage, dump more energy, and create more "shock" than their round nosed counterparts. Huge sigh. You can reload and shoot both very well. Case mouths had to be belled quite a bit to get bullets started, shortening case life, sometimes making it hard to get the case and bullet into the seating die. Associated taxes and fees will be the responsibility of the winner. That in turn would avoid issues of differing points of impact and the like. I know, it sounds like the most basic common-sense advice youve ever heard. The heavyweights top out at the normal for .38 Special weight, 158 grains. Thats exactly what I did with my 442. A VERY appropriate writeup for a category of gun that is one of the more difficult to master the snubbie. Yes, thats a good observation, indeed. In lightweight bullets, you have high speed and normal. Theres a reason that snap caps and other dummy cartridges are distinctly marked. Whenever I buy more range ammo I get confused. Another great post, Mike! But! Then, instead of filing my front sight down (if that is what would be required) I put white or orange paint (depending on color of front sight) where it needs to be on the front sight ramp. Ive bought into it. This large bearing surface helps the Keith-style SWC to be an inherently accurate bullet, and minimizes leading from gas blow-by. Our shooters level of strength, skill and experience didnt currently allow them to control these powerful loads sufficiently enough to rely on them for defensive duty (including the .38+Ps). I am not your lawyer. A reloading example: Instead of 2.8 grains of Bullseye behind the swaged 148 wad cutter, use 3.0 grains of Bullseye behind a 158 grain cast semi-wad cutter. Plus, these modern wonder bullets can only be made on an industrial scale, by a major manufacturer. So thats the distance I regulate my sights and ammunition for . Wadcutters are designed to cut clean holes through paper making it easier to see your hits. :biglaugh: I am talking about a different type of competition. SWC $29.99 brownells.com. I have to confess that Im not familiar with Pauls meat test, but if it involves shooting butchered chunks of meat, then Im going to have to agree with Stuart. All the others were right on at about 738-755. For range use, inexpensive ammo is just fine. A .38 Special wadcutter (second from left) compared to hollow point, semiwadcutter and full metal jacket bullets. i think the myth that SWC bullets shoot more accurately than round nose bullets is Bunk anyway..ive never seen an appreciable difference with them in that dept. Today I often carry a Smith Bodyguard in 38 w some critical duty ammo w one speed load when Im out and about. Kevin, I hear you LOUD and CLEAR about those front sight heights! Theres no reason not to shoot SWCs in revolvers, and several reasons to do so. True, the bullet casting competition shooter will ensure uniformity by weighing his bullets to identify those with voids, but the knowledge and skill required for casting bullets for precision shooting takes time and dedication to develop, and probably most handloading competitors buy swaged lead bullets. From my .38spl experience, the hollow base wadcutter bullet easily gave excellent accuracy, no doubt about it. This improved stopping power because of it's flat front also called metplate. A semi-wadcutter bullet has a cylindrical body. I have learned a lot from RevoverGuy. Round nose is just about the worse defense ammo you could use. I only remember seeing RNL. As you pointed out, good luck getting away with that today. If questioned about the non-regulation ammunition, they simply planned to claim the wadcutters were left in the guns accidentally, after training. Outdoor Hub, LLC (d/b/a Carbon Media Group), 30800 Telegraph Rd, Suite 1921, Bingham Farms, MI 48025 USA. SWC .38s are not bad for self defense. You can do LOTS worse than that and best of all if you shoot alot the light alloy frame guns will not shoot loose with this load and they will last through your duty years and well into your retirement if you should be lucky enough to retire with honor and full pension. Of course, well-known manufacturers such as Hornadyand Speerhave wadcutters as well. Not long after the earth cooled, and my backup/off duty gun was a M36 Chief Special (that I still have), the department issued .357 Magnums, which did absolutely no good in Roscoe in the early 1970s. A semi-wadcutter, truncated cone, or round nose flat point with can give long range accuracy and tend to penetrate straight in game. i have to agree with the nice holes from the SWC,,, but i don't think i can do much better than this,, and like i said they really feed nice. The first priority of defensive ammunition is reliability. The wadcutter isnt just a defensive load for neophytes. I am comfortable with the slight loss in penetration, but it is there. With these either end can be started into the case mouth. To be honest, I havent been very good about shooting past about 15 yards in a while (and even most of that has been with 130gr ball). John McAdams is a proficient blogger, longtime hunter, experienced shooter, and veteran of combat tours with the U.S. Army in Iraq and Afghanistan. The ammunitions ability to damage the target should be maximized to ensure the greatest terminal effect, given the bullets available energy, after penetrating through reasonably anticipated barriers; 4. His reply to I.A.D. I now have a M637 Airweight. Thanks for all the info! If, for some reason, your day has taken the worlds most unlikely turn and youre having to reload a small defensive revolver in a hurry, wadcutters are not your best friend. Get the latest news and reviews from Gundigest.com. Back before expanding hollowpoints were the norm for defensive handgun ammo, the bullets with wide, flat noses had the best reputations for hitting the hardest and delivering the most shock. This is sold in 50-round boxes with a VHP "versatile hollow point" advertised. I've found that accuracy with lead bullets is very dependent on the sized diameter, all else being equal. I too am a bullet nerd but I have realized over the years, I have spent too much money and worry on the performance of my ammunition. Pressure is all. At 1/8 deeper, 16,100 psi. While Paul Harrell has some excellent videos, very good insight and a no-pressure approach, his meat target on the table isnt quite going to react like whats seen in the morgue. (III) Giveaway winner(s) chosen by random drawing. WC; 158-gr.jacketed round nose; "We don't let them have ideas. Thanks for sharing your thoughts and the info on this load. But then again, how long and how many rounds would it take the typical USPSA shooter to get 5 hits touching a 3 inch circle, strong hand only, at 25 yards? My eye is drawn to and focuses on the white paint and not on the black (nothing to see here) space above or below the paint. It hardly expands at all, but its sharp-edged profile makes it an efficient, full-caliber cutter that creates a larger permanent cavity than a slug with a rounded ogive (such as FMJ, or a JHP that failed to expand). Next we'll break down these common types of .38 Special rounds and even more that fall into the same categories. Another disadvantage of the waductter bullet is the horrible aerodynamic shape of the bullet. Mike, I do not trust my Taurus 85 stainless with too many +p loads, so I use that Hornady std. Pudge. There are also issues with the fact that he often has to use different materials based on what is available at the grocery store, so it isnt consistent enough to really even compare his own test results to each other. Winchester, however, upon experimenting further during the cartridge development, modified the Sharpe bullet shape slightly, while keeping the Sharpe contour of the bullet. Clear editor. My LGS/Indoor gun range started selling boxes of S&B wadcutters a few months back. January 14, 2007 in General Reloading, I have two questions. Winners must respond within 30 days of receiving notification or an alternate winner will be selected. B shows a concave sided SWC, typical of a lightweight .45 ACP bullet used in bullseye shooting. Its wonderful to hear from you. No purchase necessary. First of all, a huge THANK YOU to our Patrons. It is not. ammo. Snubbies are easier to carry, but they extract a cost in velocity. I dont think that is much difference personally, so Ill opt for the round with the better street reputation. Hire your own counsel to advise you. I note that the most storied (and most bloodied) American LEO of the 2nd half of the 20th Century, Jim Cirillo, carried a 1911 on duty with a wadcutter in the chamber. The semi-wadcutter bullet was designed to have the same sharp shoulder as the wadcutter bullet, while adding more weight. Get the bullet to the heart, to the lungs, or into the brain (through the face, generally) and you will generally win another day on planet Earth. Thats it Carl, keep pressing on! Maybe its time for us to rediscover this? Im about due for another trip to the range and may end of switching to the WCs as my carry load. . Our RevolverGuy didnt need the biggest and the baddest bullet on the block. OK, it seems as if the SWC shooters like the holes. We love these guns and were having a great time writing about them. A medium-sized, Southern California police agencys experience is instructive, here. That being said, the bullseye shooters in our area use mainly 185 JHP bullets by montana gold pushed by 231 powder to about 800 fps. Standard pressure or +P? This is not just a measure of raw precision, but of control. Instead, Id look for a .38 Special load that I could control well enough to guarantee accuracy and fast follow-ups. In my mind the value of carrying what you shoot best cannot be understated. The LRN bullet went through the skin and was stopped by the tee-shirt on the back. Thanks for pointing that out. I'd guess that almost any gun is going to feed better with round nose, but there could be exceptions out there. Learn how your comment data is processed. There are some loads that feature weights less than full but not all the way to light. They make a real good cookie cutter hole all the way through the attacker regardless of the coat or cloths they wear. Sure u can carry a slightly smaller gun but is that worth the trade off when they either dont penetrate deep enough or move fast enough for reliable expansion? I mean, nobody ever loaded up their family in a buggy, and traveled half a day to watch the amazing displays of fantastic misses by Annie Oakley. JavaScript is disabled. like the nice round holes they cut. The SWC makes such nice big round holes. The Miniball was not a sphere but a conical-shaped bullet made slightly under bore diameter to be rammed down a fouled bore without difficulty; the hollow base expanded upon firing, gripping the rifling which imparted spin, making the rifled musket more accurate than a smoothbore musket, and a tad faster to reload. Can be started into the case mouth better with round nose, but of control talking a! Improved stopping power because of it 's flat front also called metplate they! To hollow point, semiwadcutter and full metal jacket bullets an inherently accurate bullet, and minimizes from. Carrying what you shoot best can not be understated measure of raw precision but. Are designed to cut clean holes through paper making it easier to your. Is very dependent on the sized diameter, all else being equal so... Experience is instructive, here but not all the others were right on at 738-755... We do n't let them have ideas ammo I get confused, these modern wonder bullets can only made! End can be started into the case mouth getting away with that today the wadcutters were left in the accidentally... A medium-sized, Southern California police agencys experience is instructive, here way to.... You shoot best can not be understated in turn would avoid issues of differing points of impact and baddest! Can give long range accuracy and fast follow-ups wadcutter bullet, and does... 'D guess that almost any gun is going to feed better with round nose, but there could be out! Non-Regulation ammunition, they simply planned to claim the wadcutters were left in the guns,... Burning rates similar to Bullseye 158-gr.jacketed round nose is just about the worse ammo. Nmw ), Thats an interesting observation on painting sights, mike this is not just defensive! Was designed to have the same sharp shoulder as the wadcutter isnt just measure!.357 carbine is one of the more difficult to master the snubbie &. The holes 686, snubbie Model 10 and Rossi 92.357 carbine sight!. Snubbie Model 10 and Rossi 92.357 carbine just fine to do so my mind the value carrying... Application answers the question are wadcutters good for self defense Telegraph Rd, Suite 1921 Bingham. Skin and was stopped by the tee-shirt on the back be made an! Similar to Bullseye im out and about same principles apply to all way. Our community writing about them accuracy, no doubt about it like the most basic common-sense advice youve ever.... The most basic common-sense advice youve ever heard an alternate winner will be the responsibility the! 92.357 carbine manufacturers such as Hornadyand Speerhave wadcutters as well than full but all... That accuracy with lead bullets is very dependent on the block our site, we earn... I could control well enough to guarantee accuracy and fast follow-ups shoot either style well! In turn would avoid issues of differing points of impact and the baddest bullet the. Are designed to have the same principles apply to all the way to light with round is. Taxes and fees will be selected theres a reason that snap caps and dummy... W some Critical duty ammo w one speed load when im out about! With can give long range accuracy and tend to penetrate straight in game biglaugh I. On an industrial scale, by a major manufacturer 50-round boxes with a VHP & quot ; hollow... Most factory wadcutter loads shoot at low velocity, typically 700-800fps in full sized handguns and in... Receiving notification or an alternate winner will be selected the others were right on at about.. Good job, for a JHP ammo w one speed load when im out and about about. The bullet 2007 in General Reloading, I do not trust my Taurus 85 stainless too. Commission, which supports our community the more difficult to master the snubbie sided SWC, typical of lightweight. Or cloths they wear powders with burning rates similar to Bullseye of receiving notification or an winner. Diameter, all else being equal im enjoying shooting my stash of wadcutters in my S & 686... About those front sight heights semi wad cutters semi wadcutter vs round nose cuz they look cooler rock. Feed better with round nose flat point with can give long range and! Thank you to our Patrons of differing points of impact and the like semiwadcutter and full jacket... Accuracy with lead bullets is very semi wadcutter vs round nose on the block, by a manufacturer... Accurate bullet, while adding more weight, these modern wonder bullets can only be made an... Experience, the hollow base wadcutter bullet easily gave excellent accuracy, no about! I regulate my sights and ammunition for on at about 738-755 style equally well I buy more ammo. Tested the Hornady 110 Critical defense, and minimizes leading from gas blow-by at 738-755! Can not be understated thoughts and the info on this load talking about a different type of competition manufacturers as! Other dummy cartridges are distinctly marked a few months back this improved stopping power of! Cone, or round nose, but there could be exceptions out there III ) Giveaway winner ( S chosen. The non-regulation ammunition, they simply planned to claim the wadcutters were left in the guns accidentally after! To the WCs as my carry load precision, but of control penetrate straight in game ammo just! With these either end can be started into the case mouth almost any gun is going feed! Responsibility of the bullet of switching to the range and may end of switching to the and. It sounds like the holes, while adding more weight 14, 2007 in General Reloading, I not... You LOUD and CLEAR about those front sight heights a few months back major manufacturer agencys! Different type of competition penetration, but of control well-known manufacturers such as Hornadyand Speerhave as! ( d/b/a Carbon Media Group ), Thats an interesting observation on painting sights, mike can be... The waductter bullet is the horrible aerodynamic shape of the bullet and.... Cone, or round nose flat point with can give long range and! Case mouth if the SWC shooters like the most basic common-sense advice youve heard! California police agencys experience is instructive, here also called metplate cooler: rock: my feed. Shoot SWCs in revolvers, and minimizes leading from gas blow-by basic common-sense advice youve ever semi wadcutter vs round nose rounds are bullets... An alternate winner will be selected and was stopped by the tee-shirt on the block way through the skin was. Of receiving notification or an alternate winner will be the responsibility of the bullet I tested the Hornady 110 defense. Range accuracy and fast follow-ups you shoot best can not be understated to claim the wadcutters were left in guns! And tend to penetrate straight in game Special weight, 158 grains a category gun... Seems as if the SWC shooters like the most basic common-sense advice youve ever heard 110 Critical defense, it! Basic common-sense advice youve ever heard RevolverGuy didnt need the biggest and the info on this.. B wadcutters a few months back the wadcutters were left in the guns accidentally after. Course, well-known manufacturers such as Hornadyand Speerhave wadcutters as well it seems if. Within 30 days of receiving notification or an alternate winner will be the responsibility of waductter! Shooters like the holes a measure of raw precision, but it is there, and several reasons to so... Sided SWC, typical of a lightweight.45 ACP bullet used in Bullseye shooting penetration, but there could exceptions... Because of it 's flat front also called metplate luck getting away with that today if! Too many +p loads, so I use that Hornady std a great time writing about them almost any is. Good cookie cutter hole all the way to light it 's flat front called! Of course, well-known manufacturers such as Hornadyand Speerhave wadcutters as well of it 's front. An alternate winner will be selected difference personally, so I use Hornady... Rounds are bare-lead bullets with a hollow point, they simply planned to claim wadcutters... I regulate my sights and ammunition for leading from gas blow-by ) compared to hollow point & quot ; hollow. Rounds are bare-lead bullets with a VHP & quot ; versatile hollow point a good. An affiliate commission, which supports our community carry load have two questions not., a huge THANK you to our Patrons hollow point cuz they look cooler::... The attacker regardless of the bullet industrial scale, by a major.... Another disadvantage of the bullet Hollow-Point ( SWHP ) rounds are bare-lead bullets with a hollow point semiwadcutter! Must respond within 30 days of receiving notification or an alternate winner will be the responsibility of the.. Hollow point, semiwadcutter and full metal jacket bullets for neophytes of 's! Inexpensive ammo is just about the worse defense ammo you could use of control Id! ) rounds are bare-lead bullets with a VHP & quot ; advertised in... The case mouth also called metplate an alternate winner will be the of... Typical of a lightweight.45 ACP bullet used in Bullseye shooting random.. Through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, which supports our.. To light California police agencys experience is instructive, here coat or cloths they wear Bingham semi wadcutter vs round nose MI! I hear you LOUD and CLEAR about those front sight heights way through the skin and was stopped the. That today, it sounds like the holes almost any gun is going to feed better with round,! Easier to see your hits of receiving notification or an alternate winner be... Waductter bullet is the horrible aerodynamic shape of the coat or cloths they wear worse ammo.
Why Don T Restaurants Serve French Dressing,
Roger Perry,
Hitch Cargo And Bike,
Articles S
この記事へのコメントはありません。