best portable dust collector

2022.07.31
why does my kitten chew on everything

best portable dust collector

The sound meter was 24 inches away from the units. I personally using Bosch for years and like. The air filtration system has a 0.17-HP motor and operates at just 50 decibels, so the sound is about as loud as a regular conversation. Thanks for the stats, let me know when you actually measure real time performance. When using it to extra saw and router waste it just fills up too quickly (may be rated 10L but the bag is hard pressed against the filters with less than half that volume. The best dust collector for your workshop depends on a range of factors, including workshop size, dust collection capacity, and power output, so the best dust collector for one person may not be the best for someone with a different setup. TBB constructed a jig to hold the anemometer probe in the center of the airflow to consistently test units. It consists of a hood that sits over about half of the sawwithout interfering with the movement of the bladein order to trap any dust that is produced. For large workshops that regularly produce a high amount of dust and debris, it is best to opt for a dust collector with a dust collection capacity of at least 5 cubic feet. For its impressive 800-CFM air suction power, 2.5-micron filter efficiency, and 2.1-cubic-foot dust collection capacity, the SHOP FOX W1727 Dust Collector is an outstanding option for small or medium workshops. However, there are more compact options on the market. Many of the products that we review are provided to us for free by a manufacturer or retailer. It seems to break down often and never work quite as well as we felt it could. ), Ideal test would adopt methodology as Fan Guy suggests, but with data points for multiple orifice diameters in order to chart the relationship between CFM and static pressure across the potential operating range. I cant afford to spend more than that really.I know you wouldnt have exact test results but looking for some advice or opinion on it. Our team of contractors rated each feature from 1 to 3 for each dust extractor with 1 being the best score and 3 being the lowest score. Because of the lower price, it is a bit less powerful than most options.

There isnt a bad extractor amongst them. But that will change the performance results. TBB data cannot be used for any compliance determinations. Wed love to look at your product, just reach out. It used to be that who made a product had a lot to do with its quality, but that is much less the case these days. Thanks. Second, consider moving the mic to about a meter away from the source for better representative values. Thanks for helping us do what we love. The current ranking system assigns a number from 1 being the winner of a category up to the total number of entries. Perhaps the difference is explained by the surface area of the filters and the size of the bags. I dont work enough for the former to matter much and, although cost matters, I wanted to know how they ranked assuming I could buy any of them (untrue, but I was curious nonetheless). dust festool It is very noisy, so you will need to use hearing protection when wearing it. Also two of our tool reviewing heros Pro Tool Reviews and Tool Box Buzz jumped on the case to do their own vacuum comparisons, with some great testing rigs and pointed out []. In third place was the Festool 584014. Hilti charges a lot of money for each of these things. They basically created this category and to test so poorly with a new model is unfortunate. *Noise (50%) ? Carpentry, drywaal, small shop and consruction projects. While not technically a dust collector, this Rousseau dust collection system is an ideal solution for the mess that miter saws and chop saws can create when they are in use. Our dust extractor reviews cover everything fromgeneral dust extractor vacuum shootout to specific reviews. OSHA regulations make these toolsmore mandatory than ever, particularly for interior and exterior renovation. Three points: 1- The clean filter numbers are almost pointless. It is also a bit more challenging to set up than other options and is quite large. Not all the vacuums came with hepa filters installed (the festool isnt even hepa rated). Yes dust is critical, but the performance to get the job done is as well. . Daniel Not likely to happen anytime soon. It also doesnt count for static resistance, which is going to be a sizable problem to consider for some underpowered machines. Dust collectors are essential for any shop that produces dust. Filters are important but they are not what was evaluated. Take a look at the top products listed below to get a better idea of possible options, then keep reading to learn about important product factors that can help you choose the best saw dust collector to keep the workshop clean. A simple idea, but not a simple term. The blog gives so much insight into the subject matter that it does not only become quite easy to understand the concept but to implement it as well. I commend them for being a better job than most reviews that you see on the Internet. Hence, the drop off from before/after the bag of drywall should (in theory) be much less. Sound the measure has some merit but has some issues that could be cleaned up in future work. We love not, Festool Planex was on site to knock out some punch, This website uses cookies to improve your experience. The best dust collector for your workshop depends on the size of the space, the amount of dust that is typically produced, and whether a portable or fixed dust collector would be better. thank you. Great Comparison. Its worth pointing out that the total cost may be a bit deceiving, especially with companies like Hilti and Festool that offer robust warranties. What do they need in a dust extractor? Incorrect. I would have liked to see an orbital sander test done as well. This dust collector weighs 41 pounds, and it has a 4-inch hose that would need to be adapted to 2.5 inches for smaller tools. Any chance that you run your tests with this model and update your results? To measure static power (suction) we used both an industrial gauge that registered up to 200 inches of water column, and a water column test. There are several different types of dust collectors that are typically grouped based on dust collection capacity, portability, and power. Would really appreciate hearing your views on Dustless Technologies. While this would allow weighting categories we approach is a bit differently. To summarize, TBB remains very comfortable with our approach producing a consistent and level set of results. For more information, check out our, Bosch VAC090A 9 Gallon Dust Extractor with Automatic Filter Clean, DEWALT DWV012 10 Gallon Wet/Dry HEPA/RRP Dust Extractor, Fein 69908195402, Fein Turbo II X AC 9.3 Gallon Wet/Dry Dust Extractor, Festool 584014 9.5 Gallon Dust Extractor CT 36 E AC, Hilti VC 150-10 XE 10 Gallon Universal Wet & Dry Vacuum Cleaner with Automatic Filter Cleaning, Makita VC4710 12 Gallon Xtract Vac Wet/Dry Dust Extractor/Vacuum, Metabo ASR 35 ACP HEPA (US602057800) 9 Gallon All-purpose Vacuum Cleaner, Milwaukee 8960-20 8 Gallon Dust Extractor, OSHAs respirable crystalline silica rule, Dust Extractor Testing Tool Box Buzz, Pro Tool Reviews, Coptool - coptool.com, https://www.starmix.de/en/products/wetdry-vacuum-cleaners/handicraft, Metabo SXE 450 TurboTec Random Orbit Sander Review - Tool Box Buzz Tool Box Buzz, https://rvtgroup.com.au/hire-equipment/fumes. You preferably want to choose a machine that is rated to filter out particles of at least 1 micron. Decibels are logarithmic so for every 10db difference it is perceived as twice the volume. For this evaluation we included a long list of features in our ergonomic evaluation. The tests were done with the autoclean turned on. The list of top products below is made up of several different types of dust collector that were selected based on dust collection capacity, motor power, suction, filter efficiency, and overall value in order to help you find the best dust collector to keep the workshop clean. Again, thank you for the data. I find many shop vacs noisy enough that I wear hearing protection when using them. However, it can be dangerous for your lungs when inhaled. DEWALT struggled in this test and was significantly lower than the rest of the field. This is because they need to remain small to stay portable. My work has the hilti you tested and is, as you concluded, a superior product. You can learn more about this topic in the following article: using fleece bags in dust extractors. Below is a chart showing current pricing (at the time of this publication) for each of the dust extractors that we tested. Mounted or fixed dust collectors are installed on the wall or ceiling to help save space in a crowded workshop. These handy tools range from larger-capacity units to smaller, portable models. It has a 1.0 HP motor, which is a bit lower than most on the market. For keeping your lungs healthy, even the best dust collection systems fall short. The air volume or suction ability of the dust collector can be about 100 to 150 CFM for shop vacs and dust extractors, but typically a dust collector will have about 400 to 500 CFM. Not to mention the original vacuum to automatically back pulse filters clean while working. Just use the included remote control to set the air suction power, turn the air filtration system on or off, and even set a programmable timer to shut the system off after the scheduled period of time. Warren There are situations where fleece bags make sense even with drywall dust. Others have conducted filter tests and they based on industry standards (ASHRAE for example). Todd Fratzel, thank you for this post. Weve covered woodworking models like the FestoolCT 36 BC Cleantex and the popularDeWalt HEPA vacuum DWV012. Most of these dust extractors are made by two or three specialist companies that most people have never heard of. Would like to know how the Dustless HEPA Wet Dry Vacuum stacks up. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Super cheap products and high-end products all get made in the same facilities and to different specs. However, if any of your guys (or indeed readers) have any experience with the later models Vs the earlier DeWalt/Makiita Id be interested in any insights. Thanks for these tests! The hood is compact and easy to set up or fold down for simple storage, but a limitation of this dust collection system is that the hooded design isnt suitable for all power tools. Finally, how are you controlling background noise so that they are not intruding on any given test point? Thats what I use at home most of the time! I purchased the Hilti based on these results, but in thinking more on the subject I realized that the best dust extractor should take into account many factors not listed here in the test, such as: *tool compatibility* The Hilti, for example, is meant to fit Hilti tools, which are largely focused on concrete work. Also, each vacuum was on full power, and if available, had the auto-clean feature turned on. Because of this, putting in the research to purchase the best machine is vital. Finally some meaningful, real world data! The maximum length of the hose with which the dust collector can continue to work effectively is determined by the power output and air suction power of the tool. The TBB team has been working hard to develop a good ranking system. Its an impressive product with a 2.5-micron filter efficiency and 1,550 CFM air suction power that quickly pulls in dust and debris for storage in the 5.4-cubic-foot dust collection bag. Testing the effectiveness of hepa filters for example, that are manufactured by third parties (outside the tool companies) isnt something we can tackle. The top three in the clean condition were: The results after sucking up 20 lbs of drywall compound were: Again we see DEWALT drastically fall off and this is due to its struggle in the suction testing above. For the Dust Extractor Head-to-Head we evaluated the tools in the following categories: All of these tests and evaluations were performed by our Tool Box Buzz Team of contractors. The Hilti and the Bosch are both made by Krcher. It is so cheap for a reason, and many people arent going to get much use out of this machine. Many manufacturers include features that are not strictly necessary for the dust collector to function, but they help to increase product efficacy and improve on the dust collector design. No one dreams about upgrading their dust collector or looks forward to the release of a new model. These cookies do not store any personal information.

The WEN 3401 Dust Collector is no different. It is great that you did all big tool companies, but the best portable small dust vacuum is an American Made one, Pulse-Bac, why was this brand not included? Hilti offers a 20 year limited warranty and a 2 year wear and tear warranty and Festool offers full coverage for 3 years, both are significantly longer than any of the other tool manufacturers. I may see this position for cfm, but for static readings it may be incorrect. Youll need to change and clean it often. It isnt particularly bad, but it isnt our favorite either. Henry Good morning. The only thing is you left the best vacuum by far in this market off the test. The average score across each category was used to rank the dust extractors with the top three being: The toughest part of these Tool Box Buzz Head-to-Head evaluations is coming up with an overall winner. They used an insulated box to reduce Shop-Vac noise with foam rubber or styrofoam. When I bought my house, I wanted my living room to be my woodworking studio. With the makita discontinued, any idea how the new VC4210L compares? Everything else is honestly only interesting. What about the professional and amateur woodworker? collector dust portable zoom Two-stage filtration is the best option. Mark Each extractor was plugged into the same power sources at each test. One question related to the pics of the anemometer. Copyright 2022 Acton Media Inc. All rights reserved. All rights reserved. Some feedback on what I bought got the Makita VC4210 and using it with bags. The snap-in option can be easier than others, but it takes a bit of time to get used to it. Youre certainly entitled to your opinion. The bag is tiny and fills up quickly. So I would first go threw the categories being tested & give a 1-100 level of importance to total score, This does add a confusion factor though. I looked in Amazon and the new model does not have great reviews (for what its worth), so I am curious how much alike is with the older model. It also makes it more durable than a plastic impeller, for example. Some manufacturers do show both hose-end and blower-end specs but I didnt see that breakdown from Makita. Nilfisk is the original equipment manufacturer for a number of the extractors in this test. You can also subscribe without commenting. Good catch, Rob. You can only really compare the performance of specific models from specific brands, with some general brand reliability and warranty factored in. Once the Corona virus shut-down ends here I will take my flow measuring system to their shop and get some readings on new and used Dustless vacs for you. What about air quality of the exhausted air? The Makita would be an excellent choice. We recommend the SHOP FOX W1685 Dust Collector for most small shops. how quickly does the vacuum loose lift when filters face, these are the real questions that need answered, as they go right to the performance of the machine. I dug deeper and downloaded the pdf manuals/spec sheets and discovered that the website listings frequently showed pressure and cfm listings higher than the pdf manuals. Recent OSHA regulations are changing the way we work. The 11 -foot hose is flexible and minimizes shock hazards. Also, keep in mind that any bends in the hose will reduce the suction power of the dust collector.

A 10db increase is considered a very noticeable volume change by your ears, and in fact, 10x the intensity or power. These vacs are pricey, so the cost of ownership is definitely important, its just a bit outside the scope of what we cover in these Head-to-Head articles. Its almost useless on its own, but when paired with a shop vac or dust collector, it makes it much easier to keep the work area of a miter saw clean, despite the typical spray of sawdust. Each dust extractor was equipped with a filter(s) and a fleece bag (without a bag the filters would clog very fast, and we always recommend using fleece bags on the jobsite). Ive had some good luck going on the website and calling customer service, Ive also had good luck using rockler third-party attachments, Just wanted to say thanks for the effort and hours that you did for this review, very informative. Dust []. Read on to find out who makes the Best Dust Extractors! You also have to consider that you dont always want the most powerful vacuum. I have had difficulty finding a hose adapter. This helped me decide to purchase a Hilti dust extractor. Filter efficiency is typically measured by the minimum size of particle the filter can capture, or the absolute micron rating. Our goal is to provide readers with honest, objective information based on our own experiences.

The gents at TBB did a great job of doing a relative comparison of several popular units. However, this machine is just too underpowered for most shops, even small ones. My compliments on the testing of dust extractors.It was thorough, easy to understand and measured those parameters that are important to us users. Performance does not drop off like these in the test. This dust collector does have a decent amount of power for most jobs. Noise is a serious hazard in construction so any tool that offers lower sound signatures are important for hearing protection. Id like to see the Hilti go up against the $1000 makita, Perceived loudness doubles every 10db.

By Timothy Dale | Updated Aug 31, 2021 2:24 PM. However, I cant seem to find any real world reviews of Dustless Technologies, and dont want to just trust the companies own youtube videos. This cleans up the dust as its produced, ensuring that you can see the project at all times and keeping the workshop clean in the process.

Did you ensure that it was always oriented as shown in the lower photo? Do some research on Pulse Bac. In another special case, Festool, their unit has been EPA certified and rated for lead paint removal work for well over a decade. Can the vacuum power be adjusted so that swirl marks are reduced when a DC is connected? The additional power needed is directly correlated to the air flow over the wire. There are many reports of this dust collector running for years. Besides that, this machine is perfect for small shops. (After pitot calibration in tube with orifice, but thats more than we can do here.). Thank you so much. These devices connect to the power tools in order to provide consistent suction, pulling in any dust and debris that is created while working on the project. Of course, purchasing the right model is also paramount. Without it, your shop will become dirty and unsafe. Copyright 2008-2022 Pro Tool Reviews, LLC. These types include standard shop vacuums, dust extractors, single-stage bag dust collectors, canister dust collectors, and cyclonic dust collectors.

Keeping any project neat and clean while working is an important step that can mean the difference between an ideal outcome and a botched result because the reality is that if the user cannot see the material, it becomes increasingly difficult to achieve the desired look or appearance. 5 fleece bags (only come in a kit): $45.50; HEPA filter: $191; replacement basic universal filter: $121; Vacuum accessory set: $236; push bar: $220; adapter plate with tool box top: $172+$94.25; the list goes on. We pulled down the protective air-tight sleeve to zero out the meter every time We changed the units to ensure that it calibrated to an absolute zero airflow. While the mess can be cleaned up after the project is complete, the dust can get everywhere, even obscuring the material while you work. His other interests include astronomy, hiking, and fishing. Below are the results from our decibel measurements.

Our tests were conducted at the opening of the canister with a fleece bag and standard filter attached.. Our testing was done consistently for each unit and provides a more realistic measurement during actual use. Small but busy workshops can benefit from having a wall-mounted dust collector like this impressive product from Powertec that has 537 CFM suction power and a 2.5-micron filter efficiency rating. Under the cost section you briefly mention the warranty, which is good, but no where in the review was the cost of filter bags and HEPA filter discussed and what the average cost per year might be if you could determine a frequency for how often the extractor would need to be emptied. The dust collector I had seemed to create more dust than it collected. collector dust single portable stage canister The measured air flow in CFM is shown for both the clean and dirty dust extractors after sucking up 20 lbs of drywall compound. Great job. The point is that obviously a Hepa filter would further restrict air flow giving the some brands a unfair advantage. Something that can suck the dust as I sand. Sounds like someone is looking for some air-time and exposure for your vac. Some examples include remote controls, noise-reducing insulation, handles, wheels, and hose storage spaces. The manual specs yielded side-by-side comparisons that were more in line with your results. Festool might be expensive but they also hold value better than any other brands. It is much cheaper than most of the competition. Over the years, he has developed a keen interest in a wide variety of DIY projects around the home.

It does have the option to put wheels on it, which is fantastic if you plan on using it with different tools around your workspace. Well keep an eye out for next time we look at dust extractors. In previous generations, you could say, I buy [brand] because they make great products. It would be reliable because all their products were made in 1 facility and to very similar standards. I learned a lot. Thanks! I havent inquired yet my question is do you think it will be better to buy or hire? This cordless dust extractor weighs just 10 pounds, and it has a foldaway handle as well as a hose storage space, making it easy to pick up and carry around the workshop or even load into a car or truck to take to the job site. Measurements were recorded both when the vacuums were clean, and when they were dirty with drywall compound (under extreme motor performance, the sound levels are higher). How about the best woodworking dust extractor?We help you with Pro-focused dust extraction reviews thatbreak it down. The wall mount ensures that the dust collector remains up off of the floor, giving users more space to move or store items. We know you have lots of places to get this sort of evaluation of tools, but we think ours are the best based on our vast construction experience. It is fairly inexpensive, which makes it great for those that arent looking to spend tons of money. It has a powder-coated paint to prevent rust and improve the overall durability of the model. A built-in window on the dust collection bag makes it easy to see when the bag needs to be emptied, and the safety on/off switch helps to prevent accidents. The water column measure is the suction head at zero flow (one condition). Jon Thank you! As stated above, we used fleece bags in all of the dust extractors as the primary filter to prevent premature clogging of the pleated filters. As the air flows over the heated wire and cools the wire, additional power is supplied to keep the wire at a constant temperature. I would also very much like to know this too. I had been tossing up the latest Makita (VC4210M) and DeWalt (DWV902M-XE) M Class extractors. It is also very portable. Cant wait to see your results. Horsepower, air suction power, and filter efficiency were top considerations while researching these products because these specifications greatly affect the dust collection ability of the dust collector and provide measurable information to help make comparisons between products. This is just giving a % of 100. This model includes a 5.7-amp motor. I was thinking of buying the Fein turbo II for home. I know its an older thread, but such good info. Coming in a very close second place was the Makita VC4710. These tests are a TON of work, and we have a long list of other tools to do Head-to-Head comparisons on. It even has built-in handles and wheels to improve the portability and offset the 59-pound weight. The latest DeWalt seems to have addressed some of the issues in your test as the new model has two filters and automatically switches between use/cleaning every 30 seconds. Learn how your comment data is processed. Also, which DCs have an auto tool trigger feature? Each of the guys on the team is a contractor, a PRO, a guy that actually uses tools every day to make a living. While were not going to dig into the details of the warranties here, it should be looked at when considering to the total cost of ownership. The impeller is steel, which makes it able to take in quite a bit more air than other machines. Will a cyclone (I already have one) paired with a manual filter cleaner work as well as a machine with an auto filter cleaner? Dexter Im not familiar with that brand. Wood and metalworking projects can range from entertaining hobbies to necessary professions, like carpentry and auto mechanic work. The importance of good jobsite dust control cannot be stated enough. See our Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions. To help you make the best decision of your small shop, we researched some of the top dust collectors out there. Outside of the top three the drop offs are so severe there functionality are compromised.